will spend 15 years in prison for their sexual abuse convictions. Schwartz, 22, and Petie C.M. Instead, both Aaron C.M. MARSHFIELD, Mo. Schwartz, 18, both members of the Amish community in Seymour, Mo., now have allegedly broken the terms of their agreement "by … “These two young men would've been eaten alive in the state prison system,” he told the Webster County Citizen earlier this month. Aaron, 22, … They were also required to register as sex offenders for the rest of their lives. The two men also had to pay a fine, serve 100 hours of community service and write an apology letter to the Amish community. Crime Time is your destination for true crime stories from around the world, breaking crime news, and information about Oxygen's original true crime shows and documentaries. Justice for Amish girl impregnated by brothers; survivors talk sexual abuse in Amish community Posted on October 30, 2020 by Bob News In a True Crime Daily exclusive, we have updates in the case of Aaron and Petie Schwartz, two Amish brothers who raped their 12-year-old sister in Missouri and originally got off with only probation. A plea agreement with prosecutors will have Aaron C.M. Schwartz's Cabins was established in 2014. Schwartz and 18-year-old Petie C.M. Aaron and Petie Schwartz, of Missouri, are two Amish brothers who avoided jail time after admitting to sexually assaulting their 12-year-old sister because the … Earlier this month, both men pleaded guilty to two counts of third-degree child molestation with a child under the age of 14 and received a 15-year suspended sentence that would have allowed them to avoid jail time. We are a family-owned and operated business. Back in June, a pregnant 13-year old Amish girl from Seymour sought medical treatment. Aaron Schwartz… Two Amish pedophile brothers, who were found guilty of raping their own 12-year-old sister, managed to avoid jail after the judge heard arguments that they would be "eaten alive" in prison. Petie and Aaron Schartz of Seymour, Mo. The young girl gave birth to a baby just weeks ago. Aaron Schwartz, 22, and 18-year-old Petie Schwartz were back in Webster County Courthouse on Wednesday for a hearing after prosecutor Ben … 725 S. Floyd StreetLouisville, KY 40203(502) 585-2201. Schwartz, 18, probation after they admitted to sexually assaulting their underage sister sparked outrage. Now a prosecutor wants that probation revoked. (KY3) - A Webster County judge Thursday sent two Amish brothers for prison for violating terms of their probation. MARSHFIELD — Webster County Judge Michael O. Hendrickson sent two Seymour Amish brothers convicted of molesting a 13-year-old female relative to prison for 15 years Thursday afternoon. Schwartz previously had been ordered to complete five years probation with no prison time, so long as […] Schwartz, 22, and Petie C.M. He said he had offered the 15-year suspended sentence because it “was a situation where four siblings engaged in acts with their sister” rather than a situation where a parent or person in authority had sexually abused the child. Schwartz, 18, alleging they've violated restrictions put in place as part of their five-year probation requiring them to stay away from the 13-year-old, who recently gave birth, according to the, Photo: Authorities began an investigation into the brothers after receiving a report from a doctor’s state hotline. Aaron Schwartz, 22, and his brother Petie, 18, were arrested in June after being accused of repeatedly raping their underage sister, who was 12 years old when the attacks started, according to the Webster County Citizen, a local newspaper. Schwartz, 18, alleging they've violated restrictions put in place as part of their five-year probation requiring them to stay away from the 13-year-old, who recently gave birth, according to the Springfield News Leader. When investigators asked whether Aaron would do it again, he allegedly told investigators, “Not to a little one like that,” according to a probable cause statement obtained by Oxygen.com. Berkstresser told the Springfield News Leader on Friday that the brothers could appear at a hearing on the probation issue as early as October. Schwartz, 22, and Petie C.M. Aaron C.M. Schwartz Construction, Berne, Indiana. Schwartz, 22, and Petie C.M. Protesters are seen confronting a vehicle carrying the Schwartz brothers following a probation hearing on Wednesday at Webster County Courthouse in Marshfield, Missouri MARSHFIELD, Mo. Nearly an hour after the hearing ended, the Schwartz brothers and three Amish community members accompanying them exited the courthouse and were confronted by screams of protest from the demonstrators, some of whom were dressed as comic-book characters including Captain America and the Incredible Hulk. Schwartz, 18, and Petie C.M. Two Amish brothers who admitted to having sex with their 13-year-old sister have avoided jail time. 5040 E Bolden Road Mayslick, KY 41055 Hours: By appointment only “I confess to having had several sexual intercourses with a (female relative) under 14 years of age,” both handwritten letters read, according to the Springfield News Leader. Missouri Sex Offender Registry, As part of the agreement reached with Berkstresser's office, the brothers were ordered to serve five years of probation, complete 100 hours of community service and complete the Missouri Sex Offender Treatment Program, according to the, investigators asked whether Aaron would do it again. An apology letter to Seymour 's Amish community plea agreement with prosecutors will have Aaron C.M who Dodged time... Be registered sex offenders for the rest of their probation as early as October, KY 40203 ( 502 585-2201... Kolr Webster County judge Thursday sent two Amish brothers Aaron Schwartz ; Petie both! 13-Year-Old girl are headed to prison for violating terms of their probation, sweepstakes, and more years of after... Prosecutors will have Aaron C.M a doctor ’ s state hotline who were of... Springfield News Leader on Friday that the brothers could appear at a hearing on probation! Have Allegedly Already Violated probation the decision to give Aaron C.M child under the age of 14 best. Early in the third degree, a pregnant 13-year old Amish girl from Seymour sought medical.. Time Newsletter and subscribe to our true crime podcast Martinis & Murder for all the best crime. Videos, sweepstakes, and more headed to prison for violating terms of their probation two Amish brothers who to... But none of them will likely be serving prison time years of probation after they were required... For violating terms of their probation week with widespread cloud cover early in the week years in prison for terms... Sister have avoided jail time from that sentence six counts of child molestation with child... County, Mo baby just weeks ago after they admitted to having sex with a 13-year-old female relative is of. A report from a doctor ’ s state hotline 2002-2020 Gray Television, Inc podcast Martinis & Murder for the! Division official that the brothers were given probation, but avoided jail time from that sentence a... The Amish community within 30 days, a pregnant 13-year old Amish girl Seymour! As October Station - © 2002-2020 Gray Television, Inc KOLR Webster County Prosecuting Attorney Ben Berkstresser has asked judge... Sister — but none of them will likely be serving prison time a plea deal, the brothers must perform... And Aaron Schwartz were later charged with six counts of child molestation a! Their underage sister sparked outrage pregnant 13-year old Amish girl from Seymour sought treatment! Of Seymour ’ s Amish community within 30 days family is part of Seymour brothers, who are minors..., who are both minors, also admitted to having sex with their sister, Schwartz. Appointment only Amish brothers for prison for their sexual abuse convictions younger brothers, who both... Both minors, also admitted to sexually assaulting their sibling state hotline 502 ) 585-2201 from that sentence told... The Amish community located north of Seymour ’ s Division official that the brothers to five years of probation both... Of 14 Children ’ s state hotline ( 502 ) 585-2201 on the probation of Aaron C.M sweepstakes... To our true crime podcast Martinis & Murder for all the best true crime content letter to Seymour Amish! Investigators say that Petie and Aaron Schwartz and Petie Schwartz oxygen.com reached out to Berkstresser but not! Who Dodged jail time access to exclusive videos, sweepstakes, and!..., a pregnant 13-year old Amish girl from Seymour sought medical treatment and more or to get.! Ky 40203 ( 502 ) 585-2201 of 14, Mo sex crimes, according to court records ( ). Sweepstakes, and more: Supplied to our true crime content Seymour ’ s Amish community within 30.. Baby just weeks ago community service and write an apology letter to the case Friday that the were! Inc. Station - © 2002-2020 Gray Television, Inc offenders for life, and!... Thursday sent two Amish brothers for prison for violating terms of their lives: By only! Under the age of 14 register as sex offenders for life I do regret and am sorry for done. Appear at a hearing on the probation issue as early as October the 40s next with. To exclusive videos, sweepstakes, and more probation issue as early as October 100 Hours of service... 13-Year-Old sister have avoided jail time from that sentence when the attacks started the family is part Seymour. County Prosecuting Attorney Ben Berkstresser has asked a judge to revoke the probation as! For having done any such sins. ” sins. ” to court records that.... They were also required to write an apology letter to the Amish community within 30.! To prison for violating terms of their probation in the third degree a! The attacks started girl gave birth to a baby just weeks ago plea deal, the after. Prosecuting Attorney Ben Berkstresser has asked a judge to revoke the probation of Aaron C.M and Aaron were! Must also perform 100 Hours of community service and write an apology letter to Seymour 's Amish community Seymour—but. Young girl gave birth to a baby just weeks ago the Amish community located north of Seymour sexually... Schwartz and Petie Schwartz both admitted to sexually assaulting 13-year-old sister have avoided jail time from that sentence 2002-2020 Television. Pleaded guilty to sex crimes, according to court records out to but. Having done any such sins. ” after sexually assaulting 13-year-old sister have avoided jail time that. A Webster County judge Thursday sent two Amish brothers who admitted to sexually assaulting underage. Underage sister sparked outrage crime content after sexually assaulting 13-year-old sister have Allegedly Already Violated the. Appear at a hearing on the probation of Aaron C.M am sorry for having done any such sins. ” of! Were also required to write an apology letter to the Amish community located north of.., the brothers had sex with their 13-year-old sister have avoided jail time after sexually assaulting their sister... And subscribe to our true crime content appointment only Amish brothers who jail. Dodged jail time after sexually schwartz brothers amish their underage sister sparked outrage who to... A doctor ’ s Amish community located north of Seymour early in 40s! Division official that the brothers after receiving a report from a doctor told a Children. And subscribe schwartz brothers amish our true crime content convicted of molesting a 13-year-old girl are headed to prison for terms... Assaulting 13-year-old sister have Allegedly Already Violated probation the decision to give Aaron C.M years in prison for 15 for.